Introduction
TWoL: So, I exhort the elders among you, as a fellow elder and a witness of the sufferings of Christ, as well as a partaker in the glory that is going to be revealed:
One of the questions I was asked when you all were considering me to be your pastor—and I checked my emails because it was emailed to me—was, “how long do you think you’ll be at TCBC? Do you see yourself being [here] longer than 5 years? Or do you view this position as a means toward another pastoral position at another church someday?” And I remember thinking, I could give the best possible answer, but how will he know that I’m telling the truth?
I didn’t know how to convince this person that what I was going to say was from the heart. And I realized very quickly that the only way to prove my answer to him was to do, as best as I can, what I told him and to create, build, and foster a sense of trust not just with this individual who asked the question, but with all of you—not to betray you, knowing we’ll all make mistakes in this together, but also collectively working on this project called church, empowered by the Spirit, willed by the Father, until our Saviour takes us home.
What was the response I gave to that question? I responded: “If you guys hire me, I hope to be [here] for the rest of my life.” It’s now been almost five years, and though I pray there’s still lots of time left in my life and in the life of this church, I hope that I’ve gained your trust—that it doesn’t feel like you’re my five-year plan to get to something else.
Sure, I will admit I wish we did or do some things differently, just like I’m sure you wish I did or do some things differently, but just because you’re imperfect doesn’t mean my love for you all as a pastor has waned in the slightest. And I don’t mean to be overly sentimental, but my unceasing growth in love for you all since receiving that question has made it an impossible reality for me to ever leave you willingly. Like a pirate clinging to his chest of treasure, you or God would have to pry this pastorate away from my cold dead hands, and I pray, also, that that might never be the case.
The reason why I’m sharing this with you is because over the next two or three weeks, including this morning, these sermons are going to be personal—personal for me and personal for you. I’m going to say some things this morning, next week, and maybe the week after that you might think are attacks from me against you, our church, and our way of doing church. But I want you to remember all I’ve just said. I want you to remember my heart—ardent and sincere as I can be in this—for you.
But more than this, I want you to remember that my goal as your pastor isn’t just to grow you in your joy but to do so in faithfulness and absolute reverence to the Bible. This is the best way I can love—to teach and preach to you what I see in this Book, and Peter, here, forces us to face some uncomfortable truths about our church structure, beginning with verse 1, and I intend to expose the text the best I can to you, even if difficult to hear. In this, I hope your intention is the same—that as I intend to feed you and keep you accountable to this Book, that is, the Word of God, I’m asking you to keep me and Pastor Michael, your pastors, accountable to it, as well, in what it calls us to do as your pastors.
Keep your pastors accountable is my request and Peter’s imperative for us this morning, and you’re to keep us accountable, firstly, …
1) To Answer the Call
Before I can explain what the call is, we have to figure out where the call comes from, and it should be obvious, the call comes from God and from his Church. God, of course, through Peter, is writing to these exiles and sojourners in these cities across modern day Turkey. And based upon what he says here in verse 1, there is no question in Peter’s mind—just like I’d argue there’s no question in James’ or Paul’s mind—from Jerusalem to Rome—that it’s God’s intention to place elders in the midst of his people.
He is a God of order, and as such, he gives the church elders to secure and maintain its orderliness—that through his calling of them, they might govern and teach the church about its calling to reflect the nature and character of God. There is not a church in the New Testament without eldership as the leading, governing authority—the congregation is ultimately accountable, but it is meant to be elders—not deacons, not councils, not boards and committees—elders who guide, intercede for, and instruct their people.
John Piper puts it this way, “When you lock yourself into a rigid, structured constitution with many boards, many committees, and many offices outside of the two given in Scripture, it’s a dreadful mistake. If the church doesn’t have the size to fill all those offices, it’s a prescription for carnal leadership. There are churches being governed by fleshly people with no spiritual life all over the country because of constitutions that mandate certain levels of leadership, and there aren’t the people to fill them. The least unfit are called, and that’s not a way to call anybody into spiritual leadership at any level, whether it’s the committees or your more ruling type organizations.” TCBC, does this sound familiar to us?
Elders are meant to lead and govern the church for God’s pleasure and his people’s happy holiness. And if I can elaborate on that, it’s never meant to be just one elder per church, but a call given to multiple elders in each church. In every instance where God, through an apostle or a biblical author, addresses a church’s core, it’s almost always to elders in the plural. See, here, with Peter. It’s not, “I exhort you, elders, deacons, and council members.” It’s, “I exhort you, elders.” Elders are called to work together in orderliness, in discernment of God’s will, by leading, preaching, teaching, guarding, and caring for their church.
So, then, the follow-up question is: what is the Church? Well, if you’ve been to my membership class, you’ll know what a church is not. It’s not a club or voluntary organization where membership is optional. For how can an elder care for people he doesn’t know are committed to his care? It’s not a group of friends or friendly people who share an interest in religious things and gather weekly to talk about God. It’s not a service provider for customers. It’s not something we do that is meant to be separate or siloed from the other parts of our lives. We shouldn’t be teaching people that church is just one thing to do along with work or school. No, it is the thing to do, and all other things in our lives, outside of our own marriages, should come second to church. Why?
Because Paul in Ephesians 5 calls the Church the Bride of Christ. He says, in his exhortation to husbands, “Husbands, love your wives, like Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her, that he might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water with the word, so that he might present the church to himself in splendor, without spot or wrinkle or any such thing, that she might be holy and without blemish.” Why? Because she is meant to be his bride—his beloved—his most cherished—his first and, unlike brides here on earth, his forever ministry.
So, one thing we’re meant to understand—and understand deeply—is that what we are, as God’s church, is the Bride of Christ. Think of how highly the Bible speaks of marriage—how your husband or wife is to be your first ministry. Well, here, the Bible says the Church is the bride of Christ, which ought to tell us how important this ministry—this place—these people are to him. She’s his bride who’s meant to be brought to him in purity, splendidness, and beauty—as a Groom worthy to be honoured for his love and care and intentionality over us. We become his first ministry, and so, it demands our utmost care and attention.
Yet, Paul doesn’t just say the Church is the Bride of Christ. He also says we are the Body of Christ (Eph 5)—that is every member of the Church belongs to Jesus, and we belong one to another. It’s as Paul says in 1 Corinthians 12: “The eye cannot say to the hand, ‘I have no need of you,’ nor again the head to the feet, ‘I have no need of you.’ On the contrary, the parts of the body that seem to be weaker are indispensable.”
In this way, the Church isn’t just the bride of Christ, but every single member that is a part of the church—weaker, younger, less spiritual, less intelligent, less relatable—every single part is indispensable—is utterly crucial—to the whole. There is not one that is less important than all the others, and there is not one, pastors included, that is more important than all the others. All are integral to the one head who is Christ, and if all are integral and precious and indispensable to him, then so, too, for each of us who are in him.
So, we are the bride of Christ, the body of Christ, and thirdly, we are the temple or household of God. Hebrews 3:6: “Christ is faithful over God’s house as a Son. And we are his house if, indeed, we hold fast our confidence and our boasting in our hope.” Or Ephesians 2:19-22: “So, then, you are no longer strangers and aliens, but you’re are fellow citizens with the saints and members of the household of God, built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone, in whom the whole structure, being joined together grows into a holy temple in the Lord. In him, you also are being built together into a dwelling place for God by the Spirit.”
As Christ’s bride and as Christ’s body, each of you, together—joined by the Spirit, are the place in which God intends to reside now and forevermore. This is why the church is different from all other things and institutions and organisms in the entire world. Because God dwells in the assembly and in the assembling of his people differently—more intimately—more personally—more powerfully—than in any other place. It is where the lame learn to walk. Where the blind come to see. Where dead hearts are brought into everlasting light and life. The Church is God’s holy habitation.
And it is because the Church is God’s holy dwelling place—that it is meant to be the pillar and support for what is true. 1 Timothy 3:14-15: “I am writing these things to you so that, if I delay, you may know how one ought to behave in the household of God, which is the church of the living God, a pillar and buttress of the truth.” In other words, the Church is not the Church—our church is not a church—if we are not zealous and uncompromising in our pursuit and support of God’s revelation of himself to the world—of this thing called the Bible—of the Word of God who became flesh not only to dwell amongst us but to die for us.
Which leaves us with the final thing that the church is. It is the bride of Christ, the body of Christ, the household of God, the pillar and buttress of Truth, and the Ekklesia—that’s the Greek word in the New Testament for church. For those of us who have been a part of the church for a long time, this is a familiar word. It’s a word that is often translated as the assembly. But literally it’s a compound word of ‘ek’ and ‘kaleo’—the called out of—those who have been called out of sin and darkness to God in Christ.
We’ve seen this theme throughout 1 Peter like in chapter 3:18—Christ suffered once for sins to bring us to God. So, the ekklesia isn’t just the assembly of people who believe in God. It is the assembly or the gathering of people who have been brought to God through the blood of the Lamb. They’re not just the beloved, precious body of Christ, but they are the beloved, precious children of the God of the universe—those for whom he gave up his own Son—his greatest happiness—to deliver them—us—from hell.
The church is a people called out of sin to God, and because of this, they now possess the purpose to proclaim the excellencies of him who called them out of darkness into his marvellous light. Or as Paul says in Ephesians 3, it is through the Church that the manifold wisdom of God might now be made known to the rulers and authorities in the heavenly places. This is a huge task! An enormous privilege and responsibility that we have—not just called out and brought to God but possessing hearts made willing to be used by God to upend the arrogant wisdom of the devil, his minions, and the world and show them, instead, the humble wisdom of God in the gospel.
And all this culminates as the basis for our first point. If the church is the beloved bride of Christ, the indispensable body of Christ, the holy household of God, the pillar and buttress of truth, and called out of sin to be the children of God to proclaim his excellencies—if God is gracious and sovereign enough to call us to these extraordinary things, then he will, by his extraordinary means, provide the very people who can safeguard that calling, who govern it, lead it, nurture it, and teach it.
And those people are called elders, pastors, presbyters, overseers, bishops—these words are interchangeable in the New Testament. Peter, himself, uses all these terms in chapter 5 here in reference to the same office and the men called to take it up. Alexander Strauch, in his book, Biblical Eldership, summarizes an elders function and role this way: “Elders [are men (1 Tim 2:11-12, 3:1-7; Tit 1:5-9)] who lead the church [1 Tim 5:17; Tit 1:7; 1 Pt 5:1–2], teach and preach the Word [1 Tim 3:2; 2 Tim 4:2; Tit 1:9], protect the church from false teachers [Acts 20:17, 28–31], exhort and admonish the saints in sound doctrine [1 Tim 4:13; 2 Tim 3:13–17; Tit 1:9], visit the sick and pray [Jms 5:14; Acts 6:4], and judge doctrinal issues [Acts 15:6].”
In other words, coming back to our text in verse 1, when Peter says I exhort the elders among you, he’s exhorting—encouraging—these elders to be proper elders and their churches to uphold them to this standard of being proper stewards—protectors of the spiritual direction of God’s people, needing to be constantly turned back to their Saviour and his cross. Elders are meant to be part of the external answer, along with the inner working of the Holy Spirit, to how we entrust our souls to a faithful Creator who is fashioning and moulding us into his own likeness, preparing us for his ever-unfolding glory and joy.
We, your pastors—your elders, are exhorted to this—to answer the call of upholding your call as the people of God—to remind you to cast your cares—all your anxieties—upon him not simply because I care for you, but because he cares for you to the point of his own death. I stand here to tell you to go to him for rest from your heaviness and sinfulness because he is gentle and lowly in heart. His yoke is easy. His burden is light. I’m just a middleman for you to increasingly behold the God-Man.
And yet, we are specifically instituted and authorized to this office by God, by his Word, and by his Church to govern, to teach, to care, to shepherd so that you, the bride, might be presented blameless—so that you, the body, might be held intact without any missing members—so that you, the household of God, might be a holy, habitable place for him—so that you, the pillar and support of truth, might not be deceived—so that you, the ekklesia, might gather regularly to taste and see, even if it’s just a sampling, of the goodness of God.
We, your elders, are called to this, and you, our church, are meant to keep us accountable to it because it’s a matter of life and death—of heaven and hell. I don’t say this flippantly—a church that does not have a functioning, governing eldership—a plurality of men who are called and affirmed by the church as capable shepherds, leaders, teachers, and carers—those who aren’t only spiritually mature but trained in and able to teach sound doctrine—a church that does not have this, but seeks to govern itself in another, unbiblically prescribed way, is a church that is treading in awfully dangerous water.
I’ve told you the story before that I was the kind of kid who loved to jump into pools as soon as I saw them. And there was this one time where I did so, thinking I’d be fine—thinking the water was shallow enough—only to find out it wasn’t. I couldn’t reach the floor, and I didn’t know, yet, how to tread. But this is why fathers exist because before I knew I was even drowning, I felt my dad’s arms wrap around me and lift me out of the pool onto safe ground, and there he strapped onto me a life jacket and gave me one of those floatation noodles so that when I jumped back in, I could do so without threat to my life.
This is what elders are meant to be and do, church. We’re meant to equip you with proper, sound doctrine and attention to the things of Scripture so that when you wade out into the dangers of the world, you’re not doing so as those who cannot touch the floor or tread long enough to breathe. Rather, we’re meant to strap you to Christ and show you in all our functions that he is keeping and bringing you safely home.
We’re meant to have the congregation’s support to evaluate the decisions, preach the sermons, appoint the deacons, instruct the people in the Way of God for the sake of your spiritual survival and, more than that, for the sake of your happiness and fellowship with God. Eldership isn’t something that’s just nice to have, it’s an essential gauge to the health of the church—a church that does not have them, as biblically mandated, is a church that is not healthy, which leads us to our second point, and that is, brothers and sisters, keep us, your elders and future elders, accountable not just to answer the call but to aim for and foster the proper character that answering the call requires.
2) To Aim for the Character
See how Peter continues, “So I exhort the elders among you, as a fellow elder and a witness of the sufferings of Christ.” When we read this, we’re meant to ask ourselves, why does Peter identify himself like this? Who is Peter to the church?
And we’re meant to realize—he’s not just an elder, and he’s not just a witness of the sufferings of Christ, like a distant observer, standing in the back apathetically—he’s an apostle who knew firsthand the cost of true shepherding. He is the one to whom Christ said, “upon you I shall build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it,” meaning that Peter didn’t have to write merely in exhortation and encouragement.
He could have written, “I command you in the power of the Lord to do what I’m about to tell you to do—no questions asked—no exhortation—no encouragement—do it, elders, because if you don’t, hell will not be restrained against you.” That’s the extent of Peter’s authority among the churches. Apart from him and the apostles, in God’s divine order and providence, the gates of hell would prevail. They were God’s appointed means to withhold the condemnation of the entire world, and because they were this, Peter could have said, “If you don’t do what I say, I’ll revoke your status—your membership—your citizenship—your adoption,” and he would have been justified in doing so.
But he doesn’t do that. No, instead, he says, “I exhort you—not as an apostle—but as a fellow elder—as someone in the trenches with you.” He humbles and condescends himself, instead of doing what he could have done in exalting himself. Why? Because he has seen and known his Christ. Because his leadership of the church—his authority over us, lesser, elders—non-apostles—is grounded in the cross.
And this, church, is what true leadership is. It is defined not by our inherent worth or skills or gifts. It’s defined by the cross. This is why we leaders—we pastors—are never meant to separate ourselves—venerate ourselves—make much of ourselves over you. We are one of you—co-heirs to the throne of heaven—equal children of God. Because every one of us whether we’re pastors, dentists, musicians, caretakers, engineers, students, mothers, fathers, grandparents—everything we are is defined either in the salvation or condemnation of the cross. Our character in Jesus is far and away more important than any skill we possess.
If you’re looking for a personal application in this—it’s that you are not to think of yourself more highly than any other person sitting in this room, in this church, and in this world. Under the cross, we all stand condemned. Under the cross, we are all witnesses to an infinitude of mercy and grace. So, the right response and posture is to relent of your pride—of your boasts in the world—of your securities or insecurities in your own person—and to humbly find your footing and confidence in the saving life and work of the Son of God.
This ought to be no different for your pastors. Peter saw our True Leader raise others up, rather than exalting himself. He saw what shepherding and discipling really looked like from the Chief Shepherd and Discpler. And if the apostle Peter responded by speaking to us, lowly, good-for-nothing elders in humility, then how much greater, or should I say, lower, ought our own humility to be? How much more willing should we be to serve and sacrifice our own self-worth for him who is worthy of all praise, honour, and glory?
It ought to be the first thing—the most important thing—that we pursue—not the last and not the least—a character of humility and godliness. If our task is to point you to Christ regularly and zealously, then our love and motivation for you can’t be based upon ourselves. It must come from One who is greater—from God himself. And you, church, need to keep us accountable to this. To humbly—as well as intentionally—exhort us to this for it is a matter of life and death—of heaven and hell not only for us but for you as well.
In this, I ask you to be selfish. Why? Because it leads us to our third and last point: keep your pastors accountable
3) To Anticipate in Confidence
It is my joy for you to selfishly seek after my godliness because in so doing you are securing the partaking in the glory that is going to be revealed, not just for me but for you. Peter exhorts these elders because he knows what’s coming. He is anticipating with confidence the glory of those who persevere in the calling that God’s given them.
And if your calling in Christ is meant to be helped and upheld by both the Spirit and your elders, then by being accountable for my holiness—for this office—you ensure God’s useability of me to help and uphold you. The Christian life is hard, but I hope, as an elder, that my being here, helps you, even if just a little bit, in your longing for the satisfaction that is to come. Your present suffering shall give way to future glory.
This is the pattern in all of Scripture. When God anointed David to be King, he didn’t instantly pass him the crown. He gave him Goliath. When God desired to make Joseph the Sustainer of Israel, he didn’t offer him ease. He gave him prison. When God wanted to vindicate Job, he didn’t stop the devil. He let him loose. When God called Moses to lead, he didn’t give him a great tongue. He gave him the wilderness. When God planned to glorify his Son, he didn’t sweep away his enemies. He gave him into their hands, placed a crown of thorns upon his brow, and crucified him upon the cross.
And, church, I know suffering is difficult. I know your grievances and trials are real. But as long as I’m here, I hope to remind you constantly, carefully, and covenantally, as your undershepherd, that it’s all in preparation for the crown that is being kept for you in heaven and for the Christ who intends to place it personally and ever so tenderly upon your brow. I want to do this for you for as long as I possibly can, hopefully till the day I die—to help you not only anticipate the glory that the faithful shall receive, but to anticipate it in confidence right there with you, just like Peter did.
I do not take this calling lightly. I do not take the seriousness of the office flippantly. But I ask that you do not as well. Eldership isn’t an optional enterprise or endeavour. It is something that we, as a church, are meant to pursue ardently, needfully, and biblically. It is the very means and reflection of Christ’s headship over our lives, and I pray that God helps me, Pastor Michael, and your future elders to do it well, knowing that the very means of help that he intends to give us will come, in large part, directly and intentionally from you.
So, I thank you for being a model of Christ’s love, zeal, and accountability to me, and I give all glory to the infallible, incomparable wisdom of our God who uses sinners like us as instruments of his hope and proclaimers of his promised joy.